Skip to main content
Explainer: Why Global Justice Should Be a U.S. Foreign Policy Priority
November 19, 2026 at 5:00 AM
updated new.png

By Dr. Beth Van Schaack

Since the dawn of the field of international criminal justice, the United States has helped advance the principle that grave international crimes should not go unpunished. It has done this by building justice institutions, collecting and sharing evidence with global prosecutors, tracking and building cases against perpetrators, responding to the needs of survivors, and supporting inclusive transitional justice mechanisms around the world.

The Trump administration has betrayed this proud legacy by ceasing this work, dismantling centers of excellence within government, discharging in-house expertise, and attacking justice institutions with sanctions and diplomatic assaults. It should reverse course, and the next administration must re-invest in this work to restore U.S. leadership and fortify the global justice ecosystem against future assaults.

The United States’ Historic Commitment to Global Justice

Global justice means holding perpetrators of the world’s gravest crimes accountable. It gives survivors a path to justice and helps prevent unresolved atrocities from fueling wider conflicts. Criminal prosecutions for those most responsible are critical to deter abuses, signal opprobrium, and incapacitate perpetrators. At the same time, global justice initiatives also encompass truth-seeking, the search for missing persons, reparations and survivor rehabilitation, memorialization, and reforms designed to prevent conflict and the recurrence of mass violence.

From the post-World War II tribunals at Nuremberg and Tokyo to current investigations in Ukraine and Darfur, the United States—primarily working through the State Department, the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), and the Department of Justice—has contributed in vital ways to the global effort to hold perpetrators of the worst crimes known to humankind to account. It has historically advanced this work by establishing fact-finding missions and international and hybrid tribunals, training national prosecutors and judges, and helping post-conflict societies enact fair and inclusive transitional justice mechanisms.

Furthermore, it has funded civil-society groups that document crimes, protect witnesses, and support survivors’ rehabilitation through reparations and other measures. Showcasing unique capabilities, the United States has led the hunt for fugitives, offering rewards and deploying troops when deemed necessary, as exemplified by efforts to apprehend Ugandan war criminal Joseph Kony. To advance these imperatives, the United States has sought ways to strengthen the justice ecosystem in coalition with other states committed to accountability and redress. These multilateral partnerships promote burden-sharing and connect those with the expertise needed to investigate and prosecute atrocities effectively.

The Trump Administration’s Full-scale Attack


Since January 2025, the Trump administration has dismantled the U.S. government’s capacity to advance global justice by eliminating policy leadership, foreign assistance, and multilateral partnerships. Executive Order 14169 froze foreign assistance, and the subsequent review terminated thousands of USAID and State Department awards and grants. Among the most affected were programs and civil society organizations documenting human rights abuses, helping rehabilitate victims, and strengthening transitional justice mechanisms around the world. The July 2025 State Department reorganization compounded those cuts by abolishing the Department’s most senior human rights positions and eliminating the Office of Global Criminal Justice (GCJ), which was historically led by a Senate-confirmed ambassador-at-large, leaving accountability without a clear institutional champion.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio dismissed experts within GCJ and halted many of the cross-regional programs it had long administered. This included projects advancing documentation and victim participation for legal cases involving Burma/Myanmar and Colombia’s Special Jurisdiction for Peace, preserving evidence and building cases addressing war crimes in Syria, supporting domestic war-crimes prosecutions in Ukraine, and building new justice institutions in Liberia and The Gambia. Human Rights Watch has extensively documented the damage these actions have done to justice, accountability, and rule of law globally.

The administration has also abandoned the multilateral fora through which the United States once shaped its human rights and accountability policy. Executive Order 14199 ended U.S. participation in the U.N. Human Rights Council; the United States then boycotted its own Universal Periodic Review. A January 2026 presidential memorandum went further by directing withdrawal from or defunding of several international law and accountability bodies. This included the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals, which carries forward the work of the U.N. tribunals for Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia — institutions the United States was instrumental in standing up and supporting since the 1990s. These moves cede U.S. influence and weaken institutions it helped build through diplomatic support, seconding personnel, information sharing, and funding.

Most dramatically, a February 2025 executive order authorized sweeping sanctions against International Criminal Court (ICC) officials and those who assist them. The administration later expanded those designations and announced a broader campaign to dismantle the ICC (“brick-by-brick”), which includes institution-wide sanctions, even as the court pursues Russian war crimes in Ukraine, crimes against humanity in Burma/Myanmar, genocide in Darfur, and campaigns of state violence in Venezuela and the Philippines. President Trump also revoked Executive Order 14115, which had imposed consequences for extremist settler violence in the West Bank. Together, these actions replace principled engagement with coercion and impunity, abandoning victims and leaving millions without any avenue for redress.

A Dramatic Rupture

To be sure, across administrations, the United States’ global-justice policy has not always been fully consistent. Instead, geopolitical interests have shaped the commitment to this work, and it has been weakened when U.S. personnel or close partners faced scrutiny. The United States has never ratified the Rome Statute, the treaty that created the ICC, and successive administrations have taken a case-by-case approach to assisting the court. And U.S. personnel have been accused of committing international crimes in Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, and Venezuela and of supporting abusive regimes politically and with military assistance. In particular, the contrast between strong U.S. support for accountability in Ukraine and elsewhere and the Biden administration’s approach to Gaza deepened this credibility deficit.

Even so, over the years, Republican and Democratic administrations maintained a practical, if selective, commitment to accountability. President George W. Bush allowed the Security Council’s Darfur referral to the ICC to proceed, and Congress later enacted the bipartisan Elie Wiesel Genocide and Atrocities Prevention Act. U.S. efforts to stop warlord Joseph Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army spanned multiple administrations and drew bipartisan support. The first Trump administration used Global Magnitsky sanctions to punish serious abuses, while the Biden administration helped establish the Atrocity Crimes Advisory Group for Ukraine to coordinate assistance to Ukraine’s domestic war crimes prosecutions. Even as a non-state party, the United States developed a pragmatic, constructive approach to the ICC: sharing information with investigators, hunting fugitives and delivering them to The Hague, assisting with cybersecurity, and participating in policy discussions on pressing issues of international justice.

Former U.S. war-crimes officials from both parties have emphasized that global justice depends on cooperation among national authorities, civil society, and international institutions. The present rupture goes beyond disagreement with one court or one case. It weakens the system across conflicts, reduces U.S. leverage, abandons survivors, advances impunity, and gives authoritarian governments a ready claim that the rules apply only to U.S. adversaries, not universally.

What Is at Stake for Americans

Widespread impunity for the commission of grave international crimes is a national security problem with domestic consequences. Violence drives instability and irregular migration, which send shocks through the global economy, disrupt settled supply chains, and put pressure on the global refugee support system. When perpetrators expect no consequences for their actions, conflicts last longer, and other perpetrators are emboldened. Preserving evidence and supporting credible investigations are comparatively modest investments that can deter further violence and make later prosecutions effective and fair. Helping to rehabilitate survivors can enable them to rebuild their lives and restore trust in public institutions. This work also helps U.S. authorities identify suspected perpetrators who seek safe haven here. As one review of the cuts concluded, these programs are a low-cost national-security tool.

Public opinion does not support this retreat from justice. Polling compiled in 2026 found that 81% of Americans considered promoting and defending human rights abroad to be an important foreign policy goal. A 2018 Ipsos survey similarly found that 73% supported U.S. participation in international organizations that protect human rights and hold perpetrators of mass atrocities accountable. Support for the ICC is also fairly strong, with most Americans believing that the United States should become more involved and 62% favoring the United States joining the ICC. These findings suggest that Americans see international cooperation around these issues as serving vital U.S. interests, not merely a form of charity or a “feel-good” gesture. The same rule-of-law commitments matter at home—an administration that treats the imperative with disdain abroad is unlikely to deliver it domestically.

A Roadmap for Promoting Global Justice in U.S. Foreign Policy

The current administration can still change course. Trump’s successor, however, will face the larger task of rebuilding and installing a stronger and more consistent global justice policy than the one that existed before Trump. Key measures to be undertaken include:

  • Stop intimidation and restore lawful cooperation. Revoke the ICC sanctions order and related designations, end the campaign to undermine the court, and restore case-specific cooperation where it advances U.S. interests and the rule of law.
  • Protect justice work now. Restore support for credible accountability efforts in societies emerging from atrocities. Reengage the U.N. Human Rights Council and Universal Periodic Review and renew support for evidence collection before key information and capacities are lost.
  • Rebuild a durable policy architecture. Restore the State Department’s human rights capacities and reconstitute GCJ under an empowered ambassador-at-large. Congress should authorize and fund these functions so a future administration cannot erase them with the stroke of a pen.
  • Bridge foreign and domestic rule of law. Direct the National Security Council to revitalize these cross-agency functions and better coordinate with the Domestic Policy Council and relevant agencies. These issues are increasingly transnational, so U.S. policy can no longer treat domestic rule-of-law concerns and its global justice commitments as separate domains.
  • Lead with humility and consistency. U.S. policymakers and global justice advocates should acknowledge past double standards, including in Palestine, and listen more closely to affected communities and international partners. Rebuilding trust will require greater consistency, not a simple declaration of restored U.S. leadership.

Global justice benefits Americans, survivors, and the global rule of law. Accountability can help societies emerge from violence on a more durable footing and reduce the risk that atrocities recur. Rebuilding this work will require humility and a renewed commitment to support institutions able to withstand political changes and threats to their operations.