Skip to main content
Explainer: Why LGBTQI+ Rights Should Be a U.S. Foreign Policy Priority
November 19, 2026 at 5:00 AM
new lgbtqi+ rights — 2576×1449@1x.png

By Jessica Stern

Over the past two decades, the United States gradually began to integrate a commitment to respect and protect the human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and intersex (LGBTQI+) persons into its U.S. foreign policy. Though never adequately resourced, these issues became a bilateral and multilateral diplomatic priority. Amid unconscionable violence and discrimination, the growing seriousness with which the United States treated these concerns became a vital tool for LGBTQI+ persons worldwide. Indeed, in the 65 UN member states that criminalize consensual same-sex acts, and the many others that legally and socially target transgender and intersex persons, U.S. support for LGBTQI+ persons and their rights was a lifeline.

The second Trump administration, however, made clear early on that respect for LGBTQI+ people was over. The executive orders the administration issued on its first day in power began the process of dismantling the resources that existed for LGBTQI+ persons in U.S. foreign policy. Since then, the administration has initiated a slew of rules, policies, funding restrictions, multilateral positions, and rhetoric that actively undermine the safety of LGBTQI+ people worldwide. The global trend line turned with it: In 2025, for the first time in nearly a decade, the number of countries criminalizing consensual same-sex acts rose.

A Late, Uneven, but Real Commitment

For most of the last century, the respectful inclusion of LGBTQI+ rights in U.S. foreign policy was unimaginable. Beginning in the late 1940s, the State Department treated homosexuality as a national security risk, assuming LGBTQI+ public servants were uniquely vulnerable to blackmail. Executive Order 10450 codified that judgment in 1953, listing "sexual perversion" among the grounds for exclusion from federal service and triggering the purge known as the “Lavender Scare.” Thousands lost their careers, and those who remained lived in secrecy. The State Department did not lift its own Foreign Service ban until 1977, and the order's clearance language survived until 1995. For decades, it was unfathomable that LGBTQI+ rights could become a U.S. foreign policy priority.

The turning point came on December 6, 2011, the culmination of years of work. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, speaking at the Palais des Nations in Geneva, declared, "Gay rights are human rights, and human rights are gay rights." During her remarks, the secretary announced the launch of a Global Equality Fund, a public-private fund seeded with roughly $3 million to counter discrimination and violence against LGBTQI+ people worldwide. That same day, President Obama issued the first presidential memorandum on the issue, directing every agency engaged abroad to make U.S. diplomacy and foreign assistance instruments of protection.

These moves reverberated across the U.S. government and the world, providing a cohesive framework for LGBTQI+ inclusion across U.S. foreign policy. In February 2015, Secretary of State Kerry announced the first-ever special envoy for the Human Rights of LGBTI Persons, the senior diplomat charged with leading that work.

That first envoy served until late 2017; the post did not exist during the first Trump administration. Some LGBTQI+ rights work nonetheless continued at the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and within the State Department, including in its Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor (DRL), notably the Global Equality Fund and the annual Human Rights Reports.

President Biden issued the second presidential memorandum on LGBTQI+ inclusion in U.S. foreign policy in February 2021 and re-established the special envoy position, filling it with the first LGBTQI+ rights expert to hold the job. During this period, an LGBTQI+-inclusive U.S. foreign policy accelerated: the U.S. used sanctions, bilateral and multilateral negotiations, aid conditionality, travel warnings, the State Department’s annual Human Rights Reports, and high-level statements to press against some of the world's harshest anti-LGBTQI+ laws, including Uganda's Anti-Homosexuality Act. Regional bureaus and embassies engaged routinely, notably around Pride month activities and in response to proposed anti-LGBTQI+ laws. USAID re-established its own senior LGBTQI+ coordinator, and the Human Rights Reports deepened the section on anti-LGBTQI+ abuses, providing authoritative country-by-country data.

A Priority without Adequate Resources

These were historic steps, driven by civil society’s persistent demands and evolving global norms. But the architecture was fragile from the start. The special envoy office remained understaffed, its potential undercut by a constant struggle for resources. Because the mandate was known to be time-limited, the work was driven by urgency rather than the methodical development of expertise.

The special envoy was created by executive action rather than congressional mandate, so unlike the ambassador for International Religious Freedom, it was never embedded in the State Department's permanent infrastructure. While other human rights ambassadors, special representatives, and special envoys had dozens of employees, the LGBTQI+ special envoy's office had two under President Obama and about five under President Biden. It sat within DRL, a bureau that has itself had to fight for institutional standing. The position carried neither the rank of ambassador nor Senate confirmation, which had certain advantages but left it without the clout comparable positions commanded. Some career diplomats avoided LGBTQI+ work altogether, fearing retaliation if a future administration came to malign it. The position has not existed since January 20, 2025.

Members of Congress have tried repeatedly to give the role a statutory foundation. Both the GLOBE Act and the International Human Rights Defense Act were reintroduced in the 119th Congress, the latter by Representative Garcia and Senator Markey in late 2025, each seeking to make the envoy permanent, Senate-confirmed, and ranked as an ambassador. But neither passed.

Ultimately, the enterprise rested instead on a presidential memorandum, an unlegislated envoy, and a modest discretionary fund, subject almost entirely to the priorities of whichever administration held office. This is precisely why it could be, and was, dismantled so quickly.

The Trump Administration's Escalating Attacks

The administration has attacked equality for LGBTQI+ people worldwide through executive orders that redefine sex and gender in federal policy, through the funding mechanisms that once supported LGBTQI+ anti-violence programs globally, and through the diplomatic and reporting tools that gave that work visibility.

Gender ideology and identity documents. On his first day in office, President Trump signed Executive Order 14168, "Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government," establishing as official U.S. policy the myth that transgender women threaten the safety of cisgender women. Framed as protecting women, this executive order launched the broader campaign against gender equality and gender identity, asserting that "the erasure of sex in language and policy has a corrosive impact not just on women but on the validity of the entire American system." It instructed the attorney general to narrow the application of Bostock v. Clayton County and directed agencies to require that federal identification documents reflect a person's sex "at conception."

Within 48 hours, the State Department barred transgender, nonbinary, and intersex Americans from updating the sex designation on their passports and eliminated the "X" marker introduced in 2022. Lower courts blocked the policy, but in November 2025 the Supreme Court allowed enforcement in Trump v. Orr while litigation continued. New and renewed passports now reflect sex assigned at birth regardless of gender identity, forcibly outing transgender travelers at every border crossing. State Department cables have separately directed consular officers to deny visas where an applicant's sex "discrepancy" raises doubt.

Diversity, equity, and inclusion. Executive Orders 14151 and 14173, signed on January 20 and 21, 2025, terminated federal DEI programs and required contractors to certify that they run none that violated federal anti-discrimination law. The second also revoked Executive Order 13672, which since 2014 had barred federal contractors from discriminating based on sexual orientation and gender identity. The State Department then took that demand abroad: From late March 2025, U.S. embassies across Europe sent suppliers a certification form asserting that the order applies to all U.S. government suppliers "regardless of their nationality and the country in which they operate," to be signed within five days. French and Belgian ministers objected publicly, one calling it a “diktat.”

Foreign assistance and the new global gag rule. On January 20, 2025, President Trump also issued "Reevaluating and Realigning United States Foreign Aid," pausing nearly all U.S. foreign assistance for a 90-day review that terminated virtually every grant the government directly or indirectly provided to counter discrimination and violence against LGBTQI+ people worldwide, even though appropriations for this work had never exceeded $50 million a year. The administration and its allies nonetheless made these grants a constant talking point, emblems of "waste, fraud, and abuse" invoked to justify dismantling USAID.

On January 27, 2026, the administration published three final rules under the banner of “Promoting Human Flourishing in Foreign Assistance”: “Protecting Life,” “Combating Gender Ideology,” and “Combating Discriminatory Equity Ideology.” Issued without public comment and effective a month later, they condition all non-military State Department assistance, roughly $39.8 billion, on recipients not providing or promoting gender-affirming care or "gender ideology," effectively barring grantees from even speaking about LGBTQI+ people.

It is by far the most far-reaching and extreme global gag rule yet, and subsequent budget proposals have singled out LGBTQI+ activities by name for elimination. The U.S. funding stream for this work is now gone. Outright International estimates that more than $125 million, at least 30 percent of annual funding for the global movement for LGBTQI+ equality, has been eliminated since January 2025.

Institutional capacity. The State Department’s July 11 restructuring, which laid off more than 1,300 career staff, hit human rights, democracy, and justice personnel particularly hard, including nearly all of the department's remaining LGBTQI+ expertise. The reorganization eliminated most offices in the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, including the Office of Multilateral and Global Affairs, which had covered LGBTQI+ and women’s rights, and the Office of Global Programming, which managed the Global Equality Fund. By some estimates, the bureau lost 80 percent of its staff. In their place, the department created an Office of Natural Rights under a deputy assistant secretary for “Democracy and Western Values,” charged with grounding U.S. diplomacy in “traditional Western conceptions of core freedoms.”

Public health. The administration has dismantled much of the global health system that LGBTQI+ people depend on. It canceled 83 percent of USAID’s programs and dissolved the agency. It withdrew from the World Health Organization, which drew up to 18 percent of its revenue from the United States, and left the UN Population Fund. It terminated 85 percent of global health awards that included family planning and has requested no family planning funding since. In August 2026, it took over the secretariat of the Geneva Consensus Declaration, whose aims include defending the family as “the fundamental unit of society” while excluding LGBTQI+ families. What funding remains flows through bilateral health agreements with just 36 governments to date, worth $15.9 billion through 2030, a third below earlier funding. None covers sexual and reproductive health, and Human Rights Watch found no commitments to reach those at highest risk of HIV, including in countries that criminalize same-sex conduct.

Refugees and asylum seekers. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services reverted to a binary definition of sex on immigration documents in April 2025, creating exactly the kind of paperwork "inconsistency" asylum officers can use to deny nonbinary and transgender claimants. Human rights organizations have documented third-country removal agreements sending LGBTQI+ asylum seekers, some already granted protection in the United States, to countries where they face persecution, detention, or worse.

Counterterrorism. In September 2025, National Security Presidential Memorandum 7 directed federal agencies to investigate organized political violence; the Attorney General's December implementing memorandum told law enforcement to prioritize actors holding "extreme viewpoints on immigration, radical gender ideology, and anti-American sentiment." The United States Counterterrorism Strategy released in May 2026 named as a priority threat, alongside cartels and Islamist organizations, "violent secular political groups whose ideology is anti-American, radically pro-transgender, and anarchist," and pledged to map them and their ties abroad. No credible evidence supports a link between transgender identity and mass violence, yet what the strategy accomplishes is to write a contested view of gender into U.S. national security doctrine.

Reporting and multilateral engagement. The State Department's 2024 human rights report, released on August 12, 2025, deleted the subsection on violence, criminalization, and other abuses based on sexual orientation, gender identity, or sex characteristics. Reporting on these abuses dates to the 1980s, and the subsection had been a fixture of the reports for 15 years, retained even under the first Trump administration. Leaked guidance signaled further cuts. The administration also withdrew from the U.N. Human Rights Council in February 2025 and then, in November, failed to appear for its own Universal Periodic Review, becoming only the second state ever to skip it. Both are venues where U.S. diplomats have historically raised cases of anti-LGBTQI+ persecution.

The cumulative effect is a retreat well beyond the predictable swing of the political pendulum. It removes the personnel, funding, documentation protections, and diplomatic venues that constituted nearly the entirety of the U.S. government's LGBTQI+ human rights capacity and recasts transgender people and their allies at home and abroad as a security problem. Notably, this comes at a moment when authoritarian governments cite American rhetoric about "gender ideology" to justify their own crackdowns.

What Is at Stake for Americans


U.S. foreign policy on LGBTQI+ rights has always been selective and, at times, contradictory. PEPFAR's early design underserved the gay and bisexual men most affected by HIV, and lesbian and bisexual women have frequently been excluded from both the U.S.’s LGBTQI+ programming and women's rights investments. Transgender Americans were permitted to serve openly in the military under Obama, banned under the first Trump administration, permitted again under Biden, and banned again in 2025, a whiplash showing that U.S. commitments here cannot outlast a single election. Intersex people were added to the acronym and to official policy, yet the U.S. never ended medically unnecessary surgeries on intersex children at home even as it criticized abuses abroad. And U.S. pressure fell disproportionately on strategic rivals or less powerful nations rather than allies with comparably poor records, feeding legitimate charges of hypocrisy. Rebuilding after this retreat means acknowledging that inconsistency rather than restoring a golden age that never existed, and it requires building institutions robust enough that U.S. commitments to human rights no longer reset with every administration.

Bipartisan majorities of Americans tell pollsters that defending human rights abroad is an important foreign policy goal, and LGBTQI+ rights are not a carve-out from that consensus. The stakes are not abstract. Criminalization abroad feeds the same displacement and migration pressures the United States is separately trying to manage, and no asylum system can function coherently if U.S. policy makes it structurally harder for transgender and nonbinary claimants to present a consistent case.

LGBTQI+ issues are essential to U.S. foreign policy, not peripheral to it. Domestic progress, from marriage equality to workplace protections under Bostock v. Clayton County, demands that U.S. foreign policy keep pace. LGBTQI+ inclusion strengthens the global HIV response, since gay men and transgender women remain key populations in that epidemic. It supports the equal application of the rule of law, since criminalizing LGBTQI+ people also licenses blackmail, extortion, and arbitrary arrest. It also advances prosperity, since discrimination keeps talented people out of jobs, schools, and healthcare, and inclusive economies are more stable and make better partners for American trade and investment. And it reinforces the fight against extremism and civic closure, because governments that criminalize same-sex conduct or so-called LGBT “propaganda" almost invariably restrict the press, the courts, and civil society as well. In this way, LGBTQI+ issues are a canary in the coal mine. Americans deserve a safe, prosperous, and stable world, and that requires preventing any group from being singled out for violence and discrimination.

A Roadmap for Integrating LGBTQI+ Rights in U.S. Foreign Policy

The following are practical steps to reverse the damage the Trump administration has done, leverage past successes, and build a more inclusive U.S. foreign policy.

  • Respond to persecution, don’t just record it. Make criminalization of LGBTQI+ status and the targeting of LGBTQI+ people, activism, and allies a factor in bilateral engagement; use Global Magnitsky sanctions and visa restrictions against officials responsible for torture, arbitrary detention, and targeted violence; and support LGBTQI+ human rights defenders and their organizations directly.
  • Rebuild funding with durable safeguards. Restore and protect foreign assistance funding for LGBTQI+ rights and inclusive development; codify non-discrimination based on sexual orientation, gender identity, and sex characteristics across U.S. foreign assistance; repeal the “Promoting Human Flourishing" rules; and ask Congress to authorize these programs in statute so they cannot again be zeroed out by one administration.
  • Reverse the documentation policies. Rescind Executive Order 14168's "sex at conception" mandate; restore accurate passports for transgender, nonbinary, and intersex citizens; reinstate the X gender marker; and end visa-screening practices that single out travelers over sex "discrepancies."
  • Restore and codify the special envoy. Re-establish the special envoy to Advance the Human Rights of LGBTQI+ Persons immediately, ensuring the position has direct access to the Secretary of State and an adequate budget and resources, and work with Congress to pass legislation to make the position permanent.
  • Reinstate HIV and health protections. Restore PEPFAR access for key populations, including gay and bisexual men, transgender women, sex workers, and people who inject drugs; return key population indicators to public reporting; require non-discrimination in the bilateral health agreements now replacing PEPFAR country operating plans; press Congress for a multi-year PEPFAR reauthorization; and extend the same seriousness to health needs beyond HIV.
  • Re-engage multilaterally. Rejoin the UN Human Rights Council, UN Women, UNFPA, the World Health Organization, and the Universal Periodic Review process; pay unmet dues; restore contributions to UNAIDS and the Global Fund; withdraw from the Geneva Consensus Declaration and UN Pro-Life and Pro-Family Core Group; and rejoin the UN LGBTI Core Group, the Organization of American States LGBTI Core Group, and the Equal Rights Coalition.
  • Protect refugees and asylum seekers. Reinstate consistent gender-marker documentation for immigration and asylum processing, end removals of LGBTQI+ claimants to countries where they face persecution, and restore explicit guidance recognizing LGBTQI+ status as grounds for protection.
  • Restore inclusion in the Human Rights Reports. Return the State Department's reporting on LGBTQI+ persecution to its prior standard and urge Congress to codify that inclusion in statute.
  • Rebuild the human rights architecture. Rehire and retain the career human rights, asylum, and global health staff gutted from U.S. departments and agencies in 2025 and establish a standing LGBTQI+ coordination point at the National Security Council.
  • Apply standards consistently. Acknowledge the selectivity of past U.S. pressure and commit to applying human rights standards more evenly.

LGBTQI+ rights were never a niche concern in U.S. foreign policy. They sit at the intersection of human rights, economic development, migration, public health, national security, and the broader fight against authoritarian retrenchment that this paper series addresses in full. The last decade showed that a modest, consistent, well-resourced U.S. commitment could make a real difference for people living under threat of criminalization, violence, and death simply for who they are or who they love. The period since January 2025 has shown how quickly that commitment can be dismantled when it rests on nothing more durable than a single administration’s priorities. The task ahead is not restoration alone, but construction of something sturdier.